to

OCTOBER 25

 

Looking ahead one week......

November 1
is

 
Want us to alert you to timely items about American authors that you can put to immediate use in your classroom?
Join one of our literature Hotlists!!

(Hot Lists are a free service, they include no advertising, and you may remove yourself from any list at any time.)

Click here to join our Prose Hot List! E-mail

Click here to join our Poetry Hot List! E-mail

Click here to join our Children's Literature List! E-mail

Click here to join our British Literature Hot List! E-mail

 
 

University of Virginia
 
October 25 is the anniversary of the tragic 1854 charge of Britain's Light Brigade during the Crimean War. Although the Crimean War may seem a bit arcane for American students, the event and its description in Tennyson's classic poem create an exceptional teachable moment for discussion of Tennyson's poem, the event itself, and of the issues that surround heroism, blind allegiance, duty, honor and country.
 
Related
Subjects:
World History, the Charge of the Light Brigade, the Crimean War, War, Alfred, Lord Tennyson, Leadership
 
Sources: The K-12 TLC Guide to the Charge of the Light Brigade
The K-12 TLC Guide to the Crimean War<
The K-12 TLC Guide to Alfred, Lord Tennyson
The K-12 TLC Guide to War
The K-12 TLC Guide to Poetry
The K-12 TLC Guide to Leadership
 
Strategies: 1. Focus on the Charge of the Light Brigade.

2. Focus on the Crimean War.

3. Focus on the concepts of heroism, bravery, duty, honor and country.

 
Questions
&
Issues:
1. The basics:
  • Who was Alfred, Lord Tennyson?
  • What was the Charge of the Light Brigade?
  • When did the Charge of the Light Brigade occur, and when did Tennyson write his poem?
  • Where was the Crimean War fought?
  • Why did the Charge of the Light Brigade turn into such a colossal blunder?
  • How many soldiers were in the Light Brigade and how many died?

2. What were the factors that caused the Charge of the Light Brigade to be such a catastrophe?

3. Why was the Crimean War being fought and by whom?

4. What caused Tennyson to write his poem, and why does it remain so famous?

 
Activities: 1. Assign different aspects of this event to different students or student groups, and have them use the K-12 TLC Guide to The Charge of the Light Brigade as a starting point for their research. When the research is complete, bring the students together for a symposium on The Charge of the Light Brigade, with each student contributing "intelligence" collected from their research.

Areas of research can include:

  • The Crimean War
  • The Light Brigade
  • The Battle of Balaclava
  • Alfred, Lord Tennyson

Begin your symposium with a discussion of the battle. Take great care to make sure all students understand the details, the mistakes, the errors in judgment, the tragedies and underlying facts of the event. Include in your discussion a consideration of blind allegiance in the military. Can an Army function without blind allegiance? Should there be any limits beyond which a soldier does not offer her/his blind allegiance? What did the soldiers of the Light Brigade die for? What did their deaths mean? Were they heroes?

Tennyson's Poem: Be sure each student knows the definition of a "league". Read the entire poem to the students. After the reading, go through the poem again line by line, asking the students to interpret each line into plain English. Have the students now read the poem slowly and silently to themselves, taking care to read it as if they are a member of the front line of the Light Brigade, and imagine what emotion each soldier would be feeling with each line as they progress through the battle. What is Tennyson's tone? Is he celebrating the bravery of the soldiers, or is he trying to convey the tragedy of their loss?

Complete your readings of the poem by listening to Edison's recording of Tennyson's reading. Advise the students to block out the poor quality of the recording and imagine they are sitting in the same room with Tennyson as he reads his own poem. Having listened to Tennyson, ask students to volunteer to prepare their own dramatic reading of the poem. Provide those who volunteer a day or two to practice at home and develop their own dramatic reading of the poem. Their goal should be to read the poem in a way that will stir the emotions of their listeners without being melodramatic.

Conclude your symposium of the Charge of the Light Brigade by asking each student to list the five words or descriptors that now come to their minds when they think of the Charge of the Light Brigade. Collect each student's list, and compile the lists into a class list that is rank-ordered according to how often each descriptor is mentioned on student lists. Record the rank-ordered descriptors on a poster board headed, "The Charge of the Light Brigade", and display the poster prominently in your classroom for later reference.


    PHILOSOPHY: The focus of each Teachable Moment is on the student as learner/researcher and the teacher as mentor/guide. The Internet-driven K-12 Teaching & Learning Center is the ultimate student research tool, and, given 24-48 hours, every student can gain access to the Internet (from school, home, public library) and use the K-12 TLC to conduct basic directed research. This is the premise upon which each Teachable Moment is constructed.

      a. Teachable Moments usually assume student research will be conducted as an assignment outside of the classroom, thus Teachable Moments do not require classroom access to the Internet.

      b. When possible, Teachable Moments break the information to be learned into small manageable chunks, so that each student or student/group can research a single chunk of knowledge with the responsibility of bringing that knowledge back to the class and sharing it with their classmates.

      c. Rather than focusing on the teacher as an information provider, Teachable Moments provide opportunities for teachers to assist their students in the acquisition of information and the sharing, assessing and assembling of information into a coherent body of knowledge that is orderly and understandable.

      d. Remember, your goal is to help your students be successful. You want to constantly challenge them, but you want them to rise to each challenge and be successful. Work with the students, not against them. Before starting each Teachable Moment, tell students exactly what they need to know and exactly what you expect of them. The objective is to make the students look good by showing them the way to success, and helping them achieve success.

    INTRODUCTION: As the guide, it is the role of the teacher to introduce the students to the basics of their new topic of discussion: Who, What, Where, When, Why and How; setting the stage so that the students have a general understanding of the topic, its relevance, and its importance to them. The teacher's role at this point is not to teach facts in the traditional sense, but rather to provide a pre-mission briefing that will generate an interest and enthusiasm among the students that will compel them to conduct their research thoroughly and with a sense of purpose.

    The introduction is also a good time to allow students to select their topics for research. Research topics can be assigned, but students will take greater ownership in their topics if allowed to select. A number of different methods can be used, but, for each, the teacher will need to have prepared ahead of time a list of available topics. For example, students can:

      1. Select topics from a blind draw by pulling a topic from a hat.

      2. Select topics from the list in an order determined by a blind lottery of the students.

      3. Select topics from the list in a rotating order week by week (by seating assignment, alphabetical, an initial lottery).

    RESEARCH: Research is the students' responsibility, but it is the responsibility of the teacher to provide their students the tools and the skills required to conduct productive research. The K-12 Teaching & Learning Center is built to provide students and teachers the most effective and efficient research tools available, and each Teachable Moment includes a list of those K-12 TLC guides that are relevant to the task. These guides need to be shared with the students as their tools for the research at hand.

    Development of the proper skills required to effectively use their research tools is critical to student success. Obviously, students who do not possess the skills to conduct the research for which they are being held responsible are doomed to failure. It is the teacher's responsibility to make sure that the students acquire the research skills they need, and to assist the students in maintaining and refining these skills.

    The best exercises available for research skill development are the 5-Minute Quests provided with each entry to the K-12 TLC Daily Almanac. As an example, Click Here to see the 5-minute Quest for today's Daily Almanac. The Quests are provided at three different levels to accommodate varying student abilities, and the use of these quests each school day will go a long way toward building critical student research skills.

    It is suggested that use of the 5-minute Quests begin as a teacher-led class exercise for the first few days to familiarize the students with the process and skills, and then make the 5-minute Quests a routine out-of-class exercise for which students are to accept responsibility. For example, the 5-minute Quests are short fun exercises that students and parents can enjoy doing together from home. It is also ideal to have a computer in the school library dedicated to the just the Daily Almanac and the 5-minute Quests, so that students can use the Quests before and after school, during lunch and/or during their scheduled library periods.

    SOCRATIC SYMPOSIUM: Students learn best by doing, and teachers best facilitate the learning process when they bridge the gap between the students and knowledge rather than positioning themselves as a gatekeeper between the student and knowledge. After students have been given adequate time to complete their research, the Socratic Symposium is an excellent tool for teachers to use to guide students through the process of aggregating and organizing the information they have acquired through their research.

    The Socratic Symposium often can be most effective when every student/student group comes to the symposium with unique information to contribute. If each student/student group has been given the task of only researching a single "chunk" of the total information to be covered by the symposium, then each student/group will come to the symposium with a narrow perspective that is uniquely their own. This creates a learning environment in which each student becomes dependent upon their classmates for the rest of the information, and establishes among the students a collegial sense with each of the students contributing information that is essential to the group. This gives each student a position of importance within the class, and provides an excellent basis for lively discussions and interactions, as students learn from students with the teacher guiding the process from the side.

    The role of the teacher is that of Socrates, asking probing and leading questions, maintaining an orderly exchange of information, and making sure that students allocate their time wisely so that the entire base of knowledge is covered. The teacher needs to maintain control, but should do so by saying as little as possible. Students need to talk in order for the exchange of knowledge to take place, and it is the teacher's responsibility to make sure every student is engaged as an active contributor in the exchange.

    Using this approach, students will occasionally come up with information that is news to you as well. These are moments to savor. Don't be threatened by them or shy away from them. Challenge the students to extend your knowledge as well as theirs. Don't hesitate to admit that their information is new to you, but, as any good learner should, question their information to make sure they understand it, that it is factual and that it comes from a reliable source. Is the information factual and supported by reliable resources, or is it conjecture (perhaps an urban legend) that is just being propagated by the source and now the student? You don't want to embarrass or deter students who bring "new" facts to class, but you do want them to know that their knowledge will be challenged and that they need to have their facts straight when they arrive. If everything checks out, compliment the student(s) responsible, and encourage them and their classmates to "stump the teacher" whenever they can. You will be amazed how much smarter you will become using this approach over the years!

    CRITICAL ASSESSMENT: Once the exchange and discussion of information has been taken place, it is imperative that the students make a critical assessment of that information so that it makes sense to them and will become a part of their long-term knowledge. When the information discussed lends itself to comparisons, a good technique for ending a symposium is to select a list of items for the students to rank order, as the process of rank ordering requires the students to assess each item on the list and to critically contrast the value of each item versus the rest.

    Suggested Concluding Steps:

      1. The Five Best List:

        a. When appropriate, have each student make their own list of the "5 best" from the list of items. Students should do this without discussion with other students. Students are not held responsible for their selections, so it is a non-threatening exercise, yet it forces them to think critically on their own and gives them a voice in the final selection.

        b. Collect the student lists and use them as ballots to create a class list for the rank order. Count the ballots as a class without identifying which ballots belong to which students. This exercise will allow each student to see how their choices compare to those of their classmates.

        c. List in rank-order the five items which received the most votes, and ask for comments from the students. Do they agree with the final order of the top five? Do they agree these are indeed the top five? Are there other items they feel should have been included on the top five? Why do they think these were left off?

        d. For better or worse, the top five now comprise your class Hall of Fame for this topic. It is suggested that you use a piece of poster board and a marking pen to create a Hall of Fame list that can be displayed in the classroom. Not only does this display create a sense of permanence, validity and importance about the exercise you have just completed, but it also provides a ready resource to which you and the students can quickly refer whenever you return to this topic. By adding to the display each Hall of Fame as you complete each Teachable Moment, you are creating a public record that will become ingrained in your students' minds as a daily reminder of the essential knowledge that has been chosen by your class to be of the highest value and importance.

      2. Word Association Chart:

        a. When you are concluding your discussion of an important concept that you want to especially impress upon your class, ask each student to list five adjectives that come to mind when they think of the concept. Collect the lists, and combine them to make a master list, rank-ordering the words depending upon the number of lists that include each word.

        b. Create a Class Word Association Chart, and add to the chart the name of the concept followed by the five words at the top of your rank-ordered list. Display the chart permanently in the classroom where everyone can see it, and add to the chart whenever you have an important concept that you want to impress upon your students.

        c. Addition to the word association chart will: 1. Impress upon the students this is important, 2. Serve as a permanent reminder of important concepts through the year, and 3. Cause students to reflect back on the symposium when this concept was discussed.

      3. Assessment Distribution Charts:

        a. For activities such as a symposium on the life and times of an American President, it can be helpful to conclude by allowing students to grade the president (A-F), and submit their grades to the teacher on a secret ballot.

        b. From the secret ballots, a class assessment can be determined and recorded on a poster board to be displayed in the classroom. On the poster board, clearly indicate what has been assessed, the raw totals for each grade received from the student ballots, the percentage of the total for each grade, and, if possible, a bar graph illustrating the totals for each grade received.

        c. Posting these assessments will help students to recall the class discussion of the issue or person, and it will help them to relate mathematical distributions to an activity to which they have contributed.

    IMPLEMENTATION: It is suggested that you select one Teachable Moment for each week, and that a four-day period be used for each Teachable Moment. For example, a few minutes could be used on Monday to introduce the Teachable Moment for that week, and for students to select research topics. Tuesday and Wednesday can be used for the students to conduct research on their own, and Thursday can be class symposium day to complete the exercise.

    SUMMARY: A key to the effective use of the K-12 Teaching & Learning Center is an understanding that Teachable Moments offer a fundamental shift in the student-teacher partnership, by returning to the student a greater responsibility for learning and by enhancing the opportunity for teachers to promote active student learning. The K-12 TLC helps to support the old axiom of replacing the teacher as the Sage on the Stage with the teacher who serves as the Guide on the Side.

    Whatever the approach, a creative, imaginative, energetic, caring teacher is still the key component in quality education, and it is the mission of the Teachable Moments to create an environment that allows quality teaching to promote the best possible learning opportunities for all students to reach their potential each and every day.

    The Teachable Moments and the K-12 Teaching and Learning Center are resources created by teachers for teachers, and you are encouraged to submit your comments and suggestions at any time. E-mail

    A rising tide lifts all ships.

 
Your Toolkit for the Start of the Day
Word of the Day


    

Astronomy
Picture
of the Day
 
 
 


















Holiday Icons Holidays Holiday Icons

E-mail